John Giles' verdict on Seamus...

Sport

John Giles' verdict on Seamus Coleman vs Matt Doherty

Raf Diallo
Raf Diallo

09:42 21 Nov 2019


Share this article


John Giles believes Seamus Coleman should remain ahead of Matt Doherty for now in the battle for the Ireland right-back slot.

Ireland can still qualify for Euro 2020 but it will have to be through the playoffs, firstly against Slovakia.

There is a little bit more optimism about the Boys in Green's chances after an improved performance against Denmark.

Indeed, John believes Mick McCarthy's side "deserved to win" the eventual 1-1 draw. And he also believes there has been "an improvement since Mick took over".

But he also gave his take on Doherty. The Wolves right-back deputised for suspended captain Coleman. In terms of lowlights, John pointed out that he was at fault for Denmark's goal. But he also scored the equaliser and impressed John overall.

"I think he's a very, very good player. But [Enda] Stevens is a very good player as well," he said.

"When I said earlier on that they could play Doherty at left-back, but it would be very hard on Stevens.

Difficult

"I think the problem that Mick had was that he didn't have a run into the competitive matches. It's very, very difficult to put him into a match when you haven't seen him or you don't know what he can do.

"I mean, would you leave Seamus Coleman out? You couldn't leave him out instead of Doherty. I think Seamus is a better player and I like Doherty and I think he's a terrific player. But I think Seamus Coleman, you couldn't leave him out.

"So what we're talking about now is looking for a position for Doherty. But Stevens at left-back, you couldn't fault him."

But should the Wolves player's performance against Denmark change the pecking order dynamic with Coleman for March's playoff semi-final against Slovakia?

John still believes Coleman should get the nod. But he also suggested a potential experiment with Doherty down the line.

"It's the same decision he has to make for the start," John replied.

"If it was my opinion, I think Seamus Coleman is a better full-back than Doherty. And I think it's a shame that Doherty's such a good player in that particular squad that we can't find a place for him. Maybe if we get a couple of friendly matches and you could play him in midfield. But all the matches that Mick has played have been competitive matches. We didn't have a build-up to it. I'd say Mick would love to have a game where he could put Doherty in midfield."

You can watch the full chat with John Giles below via our YouTube channel.


Share this article


Read more about

Denmark Enda Stevens Euro 2020 Ireland John Giles Matt Doherty Off The Ball Seamus Coleman Slovakia

You might like

Live: Title

Description

Added to queue
Removed from queue

On Air

Share

Share

Next up on queue

Title
Description
Duration

There are currently no podcasts in the queue

Go to podcasts

On Air

The Sound of the City at Night

The Sound of the City at Night

00:00-06:00

Share

Up next

The Sound of the City with Bre...

The Sound of the City with Brendan Roache

06:00-09:00

Share

Sunday Social

Sunday Social

09:00-12:00

Share

The Sound of the City with And...

The Sound of the City with Andy Clarke

12:00-16:00

Share

The Sound of the City with Den...

The Sound of the City with Denis Vavasour

16:00-19:00

Share

Dublin’s Top 30 with Paul Bona...

Dublin’s Top 30 with Paul Bonass

19:00-21:00

Share

Totally Irish with John Barker

Totally Irish with John Barker

21:00-23:00

Share

The Sound of the City at Night

The Sound of the City at Night

23:00-00:00

Share

The Sound of the City at Night

The Sound of the City at Night

00:00-07:00

Share

00:00:00 / 00:00:00

Share on